• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Welcome to Martha's Country Bakery

Martha's Country Bakery in Bayside, NY, is a beloved neighborhood bakery known for its essential selection of desserts and coffee. With a rustic bakery feel and cozy lighting, it's the perfect spot for a sweet treat or to pick up a gift. Customers rave about the variety of cakes, pastries, and coffee drinks available. Although lines can be long during peak hours, the delicious treats are worth the wait. From the not overly sweet berry napoleon cake to the strong liquor flavor in the tiramisu, Martha's Country Bakery delights customers with its delicious offerings. It truly is a must-visit for anyone with a sweet tooth.

Martha's Country Bakery: Reviews & Ratings

Ming L.
Ming L.

Martha's has been a neighborhood staple and deserves to be recognized as one of the best bakeries in town. Their consistent quality, essential selection and reasonable price point make this my go to spot for a sweet treat for myself or to pick up something nice for a loved one. Seating is limited and lines are long during peak hours, so come during off peak hours if you can. The staff are busy so you really need to know what you want ahead of time. Cozy lighting and a great atmosphere for conversation.

Santia G.
Santia G.

Right on bell Blvd next to the LIRR. Usually busy, there are seating for those who want to stay and eat. Rustic bakery feel inside. They offer variety of coffee/espresso drinks, hot chocolate. All types of cakes, pastries, cupcakes, cake pops, cookies, loafs. Mississippi mud pie is sweet and chocolatey. Carrot cake most times have been good. Lemon poppy loaf is delicious. Cake pops are good. Because they are in a heavy traffic area, there is usually a line.

Alvin Z.
Alvin Z.

Came here the day before Christmas and there was a line out the door. I got the berry napoleon cake and it was delicious! Not too sweet. Probably would've been crispier if I ate it the same day I got it but still was great after a day. Would definitely come back to order another cake.

Duchess Stacey G.
Duchess Stacey G.

I had tiramisu and a pot of tea peppermint tea that is also my family had chocolate mousse cake. It was delicious come Martha's and be treated like royalty. The desserts-there are delicious. Love it.

Lillian L.
Lillian L.

Ah, this place has been a long time favorite. Usually packed with people in here with a line out the door. Haven't been here in a long while but with relatives in town, we brought them here to impress. The counter windows are just filled to the brim with so many delicious looking, mouthwatering pastries. Not to mention the aromas. As usual, this place bustling/ hustling with worker bees and customers sitting enjoying Italian treats and drinks. Not to mention, the long double line of customers waiting for takeout pastries, to enjoy the delights at home. The inside of this place is so packed. Not as good as I remember though. The Berry Napoleon, my favorite, was way more cream than flaky pastry. I kinda thought it should be the other way around. But I'm sure, Sweet Tooths out there would disagree. Still good though. Relatives scarfed it down, so no issues there. Berries were super fresh and sweet. Tasted a bite of the Tiramisu. Liquor flavor is pretty strong. Rainbow cookies, a childhood favorite. Never had them from here, but with kids in tow, we gotta get some. After a tasting, not my favorite rendition. The layers of jam were too thick for the tiny size of these cookies, which rendered them just way to sweet for my taste. Also the layer of chocolate could have been thicker. Still good though, since the kids scarfed them down. Tables. Tightly packed. And often, right next to people standing around waiting for takeout. Price. Expensive, so bring a big wad. Still on the hunt for the best Rainbow cookies.

Nick N.
Nick N.

I arrived at Forest Hills Stadium an hour early for a show I was going to with friends. I decided to kill some time and get a cannoli from this bakery I had seen last time I was here. This place always seems like it's busy so it must be good. The cannoli itself was incredible and came out to around $6. If you're looking to grab a sweet treat around forest hills, this right here is the place to go.

Stephanie T.
Stephanie T.

My family purchased a Tiramisu Cake from Martha's Country Bakery for my birthday. This was my first time having Tiramisu Cake since I usually go for their cheesecakes. The Tiramisu Cake has lady fingers cookies soaked in espresso and Kahlua, mascarpone cheese filling with chocolate sponge cake, decorated with chocolate shavings/cocoa powder. This cake was so light, fluffy, and moist. I usually don't like chocolate but the chocolate wasn't heavy and not dark chocolate. It was a good size for 4 people and has at least 8 servings; we couldn't finish it all.

Location

Martha's Country Bakery is a charming spot in Bayside, NY that has been a neighborhood favorite for years. Known for their consistent quality, essential selection of desserts, and reasonable prices, Martha's is a go-to for a sweet treat or to pick up something special for a loved one. The bakery offers a variety of options including cakes, pastries, cupcakes, cake pops, cookies, and more.

Customers rave about the Mississippi mud pie, carrot cake, lemon poppy loaf, and cake pops. The berry napoleon cake is a standout, described as delicious and not too sweet. The tiramisu and chocolate mousse cake are also highly recommended.

Despite the limited seating and long lines during peak hours, the cozy atmosphere and rustic bakery feel make Martha's a welcoming place to enjoy your treats. The staff may be busy, but the delicious desserts and warm ambiance make it worth the wait.

  • Location: 41-06 Bell Blvd Bayside, NY 11361
  • Phone Number: (718) 225-5200
  • Utilities: Offers Delivery, Takeout, Gluten-Free and Vegan Options, Wi-Fi, Outdoor Seating, and Catering

Whether you're looking for a quick coffee and pastry or a special dessert to impress your guests, Martha's Country Bakery has something for everyone. So, next time you're in the area, make sure to stop by and treat yourself to some delicious sweets!